Insurance Answering Service: Virtual Receptionist for Agencies

A Hire Heroes virtual receptionist answers your agency's inbound calls, routes them, takes detailed messages, returns routine calls and books callbacks on your calendar. They stay off coverage advice and pass every plan or rate question to a licensed agent. Full time runs $10 an hour and part time $11, month to month with no contract.

Updated October 26, 2026 by the Hire Heroes Data Desk.

Answering service or virtual receptionist?

An answering service takes messages for you. A Hire Heroes virtual receptionist does that and more: they answer with your agency name and your script, look the caller up in your CRM, route the call, return routine calls and book callbacks on your calendar. For an insurance agency that means clients reach someone who knows your book, while every coverage or rate question still goes to a licensed agent.

Why the phone is the first thing to hand off

Every unanswered call is a client wondering if you still care. The Hire Heroes post on improving customer service puts it plainly: a voicemail that sits for two days is where cracks start to show. When you are in an appointment, on a sales call or out at a seminar, someone still needs to pick up.

That is exactly how Glen's own agency uses VAs. In How We Use Virtual Assistants in Our Agency, he lists answering phones, ordering ID cards and scheduling appointments as standard VA work.

What your virtual receptionist handles

  • Answer and greet with your agency name and your script.
  • Identify the caller and pull their record in your CRM before routing.
  • Route by type: new prospect, existing client service, carrier, vendor or urgent.
  • Take complete messages with name, callback number, best time, policy or plan name and the reason for the call, logged in the CRM so nothing lives on a sticky note.
  • Return routine calls such as appointment confirmations, document requests and "we received your paperwork" updates.
  • Book callbacks directly on your calendar, so the client hears "Glen will call you Tuesday at 2" instead of "someone will get back to you."
  • Order ID cards and request documents from carriers when a client asks.
  • Daily call summary at the end of each shift: who called, what they needed, what is waiting on you.

What stays with you

The licensing line, in plain words. Under the NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act, which most states base their law on, you need a license to "sell, solicit or negotiate" insurance. "Solicit" means asking or urging someone to apply for a particular kind of insurance from a particular company. "Negotiate" means advising a buyer on the benefits, terms or conditions of a specific policy. Plan on your Hire Heroes VA working as an unlicensed assistant, so they stay on the administrative side of that line and hand every coverage conversation to a licensed agent. Each state words its exceptions a little differently, so check yours on the NAIC directory of state insurance departments.

For a receptionist that means a clean script line: "That's a great question for Glen. I'm booking you a time with him right now." Questions about benefits, premiums, which plan to pick or whether to switch are routed, not answered. If you sell Medicare Advantage or Part D, CMS also requires the people who market plans to be licensed and appointed where state law requires it (42 CFR 422.2274), which is one more reason the receptionist books the agent instead of explaining plans.

Cost compared with an in house receptionist

The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported a national median wage of $38,010 a year for receptionists and information clerks in May 2025, about $18.27 an hour before benefits and payroll taxes. BLS also reports that benefits made up 30.0 percent of private industry compensation in June 2026. Here is how that lines up with the Hire Heroes rates:

OptionHourlyAnnual at 40 hours a week (2,080 hours)
In house receptionist, national median wage only (BLS, May 2025)$18.27$38,010
Same wage plus benefits at the private industry average (estimate)about $26.10about $54,300
Hire Heroes full time VA$10$20,800
Hire Heroes quarterly plan$9$18,720

The benefits line is an estimate: it applies the private industry average ratio (benefits of $14.07 on wages of $32.82 per hour) to the receptionist median, and actual benefit costs for a front desk role vary by employer and state. Wages in your state can be higher or lower; see virtual assistant cost by state. The comparison is about cost, not fit: an in house receptionist can greet walk ins and sit in your office, and a VA cannot.

How to set up your receptionist in the first two weeks

  1. Write the greeting and the routing tree. One page: who gets which call, what counts as urgent, and the exact handoff line for coverage questions.
  2. Connect your phone system so the VA can answer from your business line. Seven Figure CRM includes built in calling and texting, and Hire Heroes posts state CRM access is included with a VA hire.
  3. Load the SOP into the Hire Heroes App as a training project with tasks for the VA to review.
  4. Listen in for the first week. Review messages daily and tighten the script.
  5. Agree your coverage hours and what happens after hours, such as voicemail with a next day callback.
  6. Measure it: calls answered live, messages logged with complete details, callbacks booked, same day return rate.

Glen's take

Start with one task, measure it, then hand off the next one. The phone is usually the first one because it is the one that pulls you out of everything else.

Once the phones run without you, the natural next step is customer service or appointment setting.

Frequently asked questions

Is a virtual receptionist the same as an insurance answering service?

It covers the same job and goes further. An answering service takes messages; a Hire Heroes virtual receptionist answers with your script, works inside your CRM and calendar, returns routine calls and books callbacks. Coverage and rate questions go to a licensed agent.

Can a virtual receptionist answer calls for an insurance agency?

Yes. A virtual receptionist can answer, greet, route, take messages and book callbacks for an insurance agency. They should not explain plan benefits or rates, because that is licensed activity, so they hand those callers to a licensed agent.

How much does a virtual receptionist cost compared with an in house receptionist?

BLS reported a national median wage of $38,010 for receptionists in May 2025, before benefits. A full time Hire Heroes VA is $10 an hour, or $20,800 for 2,080 hours, with no benefits or payroll tax added on your side.

What should a virtual receptionist say when a client asks about their coverage?

Give them a clear handoff script, for example: "That is a great question for your agent, let me book you a time with them right now." The VA logs the question in the CRM so the agent calls back prepared.

Can my virtual receptionist use my business phone number?

Usually yes, through a cloud phone system or a CRM with built in calling. Seven Figure CRM includes calling and texting, and Hire Heroes posts state CRM access is included when you hire a VA.

Sources

  1. Hire Heroes pricing and plans (hireheroes.com home page, viewed 2026-10-13)
  2. How We Use Virtual Assistants in Our Agency (Glen Shelton, July 25, 2024)
  3. How a Virtual Assistant Can Improve Customer Service in Your Insurance Agency (Nov 4, 2025)
  4. BLS OEWS May 2025: Receptionists and Information Clerks (43-4171)
  5. BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026
  6. NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act (Model 218), Sections 2 to 4
  7. 42 CFR 422.2274, agent and broker requirements for Medicare Advantage
  8. NAIC directory of state insurance departments