Quick background if you are new to this. Every state requires a license to sell, solicit or negotiate insurance. Most states build their law on the NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act, so the words are close to the same almost everywhere. Get those three words straight and the rest of this guide is easy.
The three words that decide everything
| Term | What the NAIC model act says it means | What it looks like in an agency |
|---|---|---|
| Sell | To exchange a contract of insurance by any means, for money or its equivalent, on behalf of an insurance company | Taking the application, binding coverage, collecting the first premium for a sale |
| Solicit | Attempting to sell insurance, or asking or urging a person to apply for a particular kind of insurance from a particular company | "You should apply for the Plan G with this carrier" |
| Negotiate | Conferring directly with or offering advice to a buyer or prospective buyer about the substantive benefits, terms or conditions of a particular contract | Explaining what a plan covers, comparing two policies, answering "is this plan good for me?" |
Source: NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act (#218), Section 2 definitions and Section 3 license requirement.
The exception that lets you hire help
Section 4 of the model act says a license is not required for an officer, director or employee of an insurer or an insurance producer when two things are true. First, they receive no commission on policies written or sold. Second, their activities are "executive, administrative, managerial, clerical or a combination of these" and "only indirectly related to the sale, solicitation or negotiation of insurance."
That exception is the box an assistant works in. Stay administrative, stay off commission, and stay away from advice about a particular policy. Step outside any one of those and you need a licensed person.
Task by task: green, yellow and red
Here is how common agency work sorts out. Green tasks are clerical. Yellow tasks are fine if you write a script and a handoff rule. Red tasks need a licensed agent every time.
| Task | Zone | How to keep it on the right side |
|---|---|---|
| Answering and routing calls, taking messages | Green | Script the greeting and the "let me get your agent" handoff |
| Booking, confirming and rescheduling appointments | Green | Calendar access only; the VA confirms time and topic, not plan details |
| Data entry, CRM updates, notes | Green | Give the VA their own login so every change is attributed |
| Ordering ID cards, checking application status with a carrier | Green | Use carrier service lines the agency is authorized for |
| Commission tracking and reconciliation | Green | Read access to statements; you approve disputes |
| Contracting and appointment paperwork for your agents | Green | The VA assembles; the agent signs |
| Inbox and calendar management, social media scheduling | Green | Pre approved posts and replies; anything about coverage goes to you |
| Sending a brochure or form the client asked for | Yellow | Send exactly what was requested, with no commentary on which option fits |
| Calling leads who asked to be contacted, to book a meeting | Yellow | Book the appointment, collect basic contact data, do not discuss plans; follow your consent and do not call rules |
| Gathering client data and entering it in a quoting tool | Yellow | The VA builds a draft for your review; only you present or recommend |
| Renewal reminders and annual review scheduling | Yellow | Remind and book; any "should I switch?" question goes to a licensed agent |
| Explaining benefits, comparing plans, answering "which is better" | Red | Licensed agent only |
| Taking or submitting an application, discussing rates for a specific plan | Red | Licensed and, where required, appointed agent only |
| Anything paid per sale or per policy | Red | Pay hourly or salary; commission can take the assistant out of the exception |
Glen's own agency uses VAs for the green column: data entry and commission tracking, answering phones, ordering ID cards, scheduling appointments, social media, email and calendar management, and contracting paperwork. That list comes from Hire Heroes' post on how we use virtual assistants in our agency.
Medicare adds a second set of rules
If you sell Medicare Advantage or Part D plans, federal rules sit on top of your state license law. Three of them matter most for an assistant.
- Only licensed reps market plans. Medicare Advantage organizations must use as marketing representatives only people who are licensed by the state to market health insurance, and they must report to CMS every enrollment made by an unlicensed agent or broker (42 CFR 422.2274). An enrollment your assistant takes is a reportable problem for the carrier and for you.
- No cold outreach. Unsolicited telephone calls, texts, voicemails, door to door visits and social media direct messages to beneficiaries are not allowed. Calls are not unsolicited when the beneficiary gave consent or started the contact, for example returning a call or calling someone who sent a reply card asking for contact (42 CFR 422.2264). Your VA can call people who asked to hear from you. They cannot work a cold list.
- The Scope of Appointment timing. For a personal marketing appointment, the Scope of Appointment must be agreed and recorded at least 48 hours before the meeting. The exceptions are SOAs completed in the last four days of a valid election period and unscheduled walk ins started by the beneficiary (same section). A VA who books Medicare meetings should collect or send the SOA and schedule the meeting at least 48 hours out unless an exception applies.
These are federal rules for Medicare Advantage and Part D. Carriers often add their own requirements on top, so check your carrier's agent guide as well.
Three traps that break the exception
1. Paying per sale
The model act exception requires that the person receives no commission. A bonus per policy written, a cut of first year commission, or "$25 for every app" all look like commission. Pay for hours or a flat salary. If you want to reward performance, tie it to clerical output like appointments kept or files cleaned, and run that plan past your state's rules first.
2. Answering the "quick question"
The most common slip is not a sale. It is a friendly assistant answering "does my plan cover this drug?" or "is the Plan G better?" That is advice about the benefits and terms of a particular contract. Give your assistant a handoff line and make them use it every time:
"That is a great question for your agent. I can book you a call with them today or tomorrow. Which works better?"
3. Assuming "employee" covers a contractor
The exception is written for an officer, director or employee of an insurer or producer. A VA may be employed by a staffing company and work for your agency from another country. That does not automatically change what the VA may do, but it does mean the cleanest path is to keep the VA entirely on clerical work. Check how your state treats unlicensed staff on the NAIC directory of state insurance departments.
Protecting client data
An assistant who works in your CRM sees names, dates of birth and policy details. Many states have adopted the NAIC Insurance Data Security Model Law (#668), which requires licensees to keep an information security program; the NAIC listed 23 jurisdictions that had implemented it as of January 2024 (NAIC brief). Whatever your state's rule, the basics are the same: a named login for every person, no shared passwords, two factor sign in where your systems allow it, and access removed the day someone leaves.
A one minute test for any task
| Question | If yes |
|---|---|
| Does it explain, compare or recommend coverage? | Licensed agent |
| Does it ask someone to apply for a specific product from a specific company? | Licensed agent |
| Is the assistant paid more when a policy sells? | Fix the pay plan |
| Is it a Medicare call to someone who never asked to be contacted? | Do not make the call |
| Is it scheduling, data entry, paperwork, reminders or service follow up? | Assistant |
Where Hire Heroes fits
Plan on a Hire Heroes VA working as an unlicensed assistant. That is the design, not a limit: the VA takes the green and yellow work so you spend your licensed hours in front of clients. The service pages list, for each role, what the VA owns and what stays with you. Hire Heroes plans run $11 an hour part time, $10 full time and $9 on the quarterly plan, month to month.
Need someone licensed instead? That is a contracting question, not a staffing one. ESI works with licensed agents who want carrier contracts.
This guide summarizes model law and federal rules; it is not legal advice. Which of your tasks is sitting in the yellow column right now?
Frequently asked questions
Can an unlicensed assistant quote insurance prices?
An assistant can gather client data and enter it into a quoting tool so a licensed agent can review it. Presenting rates for a specific plan, comparing options or saying which plan fits is negotiating, so it belongs to a licensed agent.
Can I pay my unlicensed assistant a bonus for each sale?
That is risky. The NAIC model act exception for clerical staff requires that they receive no commission on policies sold. Pay hourly or salary, and tie any bonus to clerical output only after checking your state rules.
Can an unlicensed assistant call Medicare leads?
Only people who asked to be contacted or started the contact. Federal rules at 42 CFR 422.2264 ban unsolicited calls, texts, voicemails and social media direct messages to beneficiaries. The assistant books the appointment and leaves all plan discussion to a licensed agent.
Can an unlicensed assistant take a Medicare enrollment?
No. Medicare Advantage organizations must use state licensed marketing representatives and must report every enrollment made by an unlicensed agent to CMS under 42 CFR 422.2274.
Do state rules on unlicensed staff differ?
Yes. Most states follow the NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act, but each writes its own statute and some add limits on what unlicensed staff may say or how they are paid. Check your state insurance department before handing off anything near the sale.
Sources
- NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act (#218), Sections 2 to 4
- NAIC directory of state insurance departments
- 42 CFR 422.2274, agent, broker and other third party requirements (eCFR, current text checked October 26, 2026)
- 42 CFR 422.2264, beneficiary contact and Scope of Appointment rules (eCFR, current text checked October 26, 2026)
- NAIC Government Affairs Brief: Insurance Data Security Model Law (#668), January 2024
- How We Use Virtual Assistants in Our Agency (Hire Heroes blog)
- Hire Heroes pricing and plans (hireheroes.com home page, viewed 2026-10-13)
