Where Hire Heroes started
This is the original job. In May 2015 Glen Shelton hired one virtual assistant to work 4 hours a day dialing leads for him. He was the closer, the VA filled the calendar. That split still works: the agent spends the day in appointments, and the VA does the dialing, the voicemails, the texts and the reminders that get people to show up.
What your appointment setter does
- Works your lead list in order of age and source, starting with the newest leads first.
- Confirms the request. "You asked for information about your Medicare options, I'm calling to set a time with your agent."
- Books on your calendar with the right appointment type, phone, Zoom or in person, and adds notes from the call.
- Sends confirmations and reminders by email and text the day before and the day of.
- Chases no shows the same day with a reschedule link or call.
- Tags and dispositions every lead in your CRM so you can see contact rate and set rate by lead source.
- Sends the paperwork your process requires before the meeting, such as your Medicare Scope of Appointment form, and logs when it comes back.
The Hire Heroes post on lead management tasks adds the follow up side: thank you messages after a booking, check ins with cold leads, and moving each lead through pipeline stages so you start every day knowing who is ready.
The rules your setter works inside
The licensing line, in plain words. Under the NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act, which most states base their law on, you need a license to "sell, solicit or negotiate" insurance. "Solicit" means asking or urging someone to apply for a particular kind of insurance from a particular company. "Negotiate" means advising a buyer on the benefits, terms or conditions of a specific policy. Plan on your Hire Heroes VA working as an unlicensed assistant, so they stay on the administrative side of that line and hand every coverage conversation to a licensed agent. Each state words its exceptions a little differently, so check yours on the NAIC directory of state insurance departments.
For appointment setting, that means the VA sets a time and does not pitch. No "this plan has a lower premium," no carrier comparisons, no "you should switch." Some states also restrict paying unlicensed staff per sale, so pay your setter hourly, which is how Hire Heroes bills anyway.
Medicare. Before a personal marketing appointment, CMS requires the agent to agree on and record the Scope of Appointment with the beneficiary (42 CFR 422.2264(c)(3)). Your setter can send the form and track it, but the scope is between the beneficiary and the licensed agent. Timing rules apply; check your carriers' current guidance.
Telemarketing. Outbound calls fall under the FCC's TCPA rules, including the National Do Not Call Registry and prior express written consent for certain calls (47 CFR 64.1200). Your setter should only dial leads with documented consent and should scrub against your internal do not call list.
A simple daily rhythm
| Block | What the setter does |
|---|---|
| Start of shift | Reminder texts and calls for today's appointments; confirm or reschedule |
| Morning | New leads first, called as soon as they arrive (speed matters most here) |
| Midday | Second and third attempts on recent leads; voicemail and text follow up |
| Afternoon | No show follow up and aged lead callbacks |
| End of shift | Disposition every lead, update the pipeline, send the agent tomorrow's booked list |
A setter script that stays clean
Give your VA a short script and a list of lines they never say. A simple version:
"Hi Mrs. Jones, this is Maria calling for Glen with [your agency]. You asked us to reach out about your Medicare options. Glen sets aside time to walk people through that personally. Would Tuesday at 10 or Wednesday at 2 work better?"
If the lead asks a coverage question, the answer is always the same move: "That is exactly what Glen will cover with you. Let me lock in that time." Never use these on a setter call:
- Plan names, premiums, copays or "$0" anything
- "You could save money" or any comparison to their current plan
- Implying a call is from Medicare or a government agency
- Pressure about deadlines beyond stating the time you are offering
Mistakes that sink a setter program
- Handing over the whole lead list on day one. Start with one source and one script, then expand.
- No calendar rules. Tell the VA your appointment lengths, buffers and blocked times, or you get double booked.
- Skipping dispositions. If a call is not logged, you cannot tell a bad lead source from a bad script.
- Paying per appointment. Keep an unlicensed setter on hourly pay.
What it costs and how to measure it
A full time Hire Heroes VA is $10 an hour, so 160 hours over 4 weeks is $1,600. Part time is $11 an hour, so 80 hours is $880. Track three numbers each week: contact rate (leads reached divided by leads called), set rate (appointments booked divided by leads reached) and show rate (appointments kept divided by booked). If show rate is low, tighten reminders. If set rate is low, look at lead quality and the script.
Need the leads, or the appointments themselves?
If you want a VA to call your own leads, this page is the service. If you would rather buy appointments that are already set, Lead Heroes sells pre set appointments and live transfers. Plenty of agencies do both: buy leads, and let a VA work them.
Start with one hour block a day of your aged leads and see what happens to your calendar.
Frequently asked questions
Can an unlicensed assistant set appointments for an insurance agent?
In most states an unlicensed assistant can schedule a meeting with a licensed agent as long as they do not discuss specific products, rates or benefits and are not paid per sale. Rules vary by state, so confirm with your state insurance department.
Can a virtual assistant set Medicare appointments?
A VA can book the time and send the Scope of Appointment form your agency uses, but the licensed agent must agree on and record the scope with the beneficiary before the personal marketing appointment, under 42 CFR 422.2264. The VA should never describe plans on the call.
Do my appointment setter's calls need TCPA consent?
Outbound telemarketing calls are covered by the FCC rules in 47 CFR 64.1200, including the Do Not Call Registry and written consent for certain calls. Have your VA call only leads with documented consent and honor every do not call request.
How many hours a week should an appointment setter VA work?
Match hours to lead volume. Many agents start part time at 20 hours a week ($11 an hour on the Hire Heroes part time plan) and move to full time once the calendar fills.
Sources
- Hire Heroes pricing and plans (hireheroes.com home page, viewed 2026-10-13)
- 5 Smart Lead Management Tasks to Delegate to Your Virtual Assistant (June 3, 2025)
- How to Hand Off More Sales Responsibility to Your Virtual Assistant (June 20, 2025)
- NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act (Model 218), Sections 2 to 4
- 42 CFR 422.2264, beneficiary contact and Scope of Appointment
- 47 CFR 64.1200, FCC telemarketing rules (Do Not Call, prior express written consent)
- NAIC directory of state insurance departments
