How to Hire an Insurance Virtual Assistant

To hire an insurance virtual assistant, track a week of your tasks, pick the ones that do not need a license, and turn them into one role. Choose part time or full time hours, vet the provider or candidate, give the VA their own logins, write short SOPs, then hand work over gradually across the first three weeks and review weekly.

Updated October 26, 2026 by the Hire Heroes Data Desk.

Hiring the VA is the easy part. Glen said it plainly in the Hire Heroes onboarding guide: onboarding is where it works or it does not. Most failed VA hires come from a fuzzy role and no system, not a bad person. Here is the order we would do it in.

Step 1: Track one normal week

For five working days, write down every task you touch and how long it takes. Do not filter yet. Phones, voicemails, calendar shuffling, CRM notes, ID card requests, carrier status calls, commission statements, social posts, email. All of it.

At the end of the week, mark each task with one of three labels:

  • Needs my license: explaining, comparing or recommending coverage, taking applications.
  • Needs my judgment: pricing your services, complaints, carrier relationships, final approvals.
  • Anyone trained could do it: this is your VA's job description.

Not sure where a task falls? The unlicensed assistant guide sorts common agency tasks into green, yellow and red.

Step 2: Turn the list into one role

Do not hire "help." Hire a role. Group the third column into the closest match:

If most of your list isThe role isMeasure it by
Phones, messages, callbacksInsurance receptionistCalls answered, callbacks returned same day
Calling leads who asked for contact, booking, remindersAppointment setterAppointments booked and kept
ID cards, status checks, renewal remindersCustomer service assistantRequests closed, renewals contacted
Client data gathering and quote prepQuoting assistantDraft quotes ready for your review
Data entry, commissions, contracting paperworkBack office assistantRecords current, statements reconciled

Start with the single biggest time sink. You can add the second role once the first one runs without you.

Step 3: Pick the hours

Add up the hours from step 1 for the tasks you are handing off. If it is under about 20 a week, start part time. If you already have 40 hours of documented work, go full time. Hire Heroes lists three plans on its home page:

PlanRateHours as listed
Part Time, monthly$11 per hour80 to 159 hours per month, about 20 hours a week
Full Time, monthly$10 per hour160 to 479 hours per month, about 40 hours a week
Quarterly$9 per hour480 or more hours, part time for 6 months or full time for 3 months

More on sizing the role: how many hours a week should a VA work. More on the money: virtual assistant vs in house cost.

Step 4: Choose how you will hire

There are three common routes. None is right for everyone.

RouteWhat you handleGood fit when
Hire directly (job board or freelance marketplace)Posting, screening, interviews, payroll or payments, replacement if it does not work outYou have time to recruit and manage and want to choose from a wide pool
Staffing provider (for example Hire Heroes)Defining the role and training on your systems; the provider handles sourcing and vettingYou want a vetted person quickly and would rather not run interviews
Local in house hireEverything, plus space, equipment, payroll taxes and benefitsYou need a physical front desk or a licensed producer

Questions to ask any provider or candidate

  • What insurance or CRM experience does the person have, and can I talk to them before they start?
  • What are the working hours, and do they overlap with my phone peaks in my time zone?
  • Is there a contract or minimum term, and what is the notice period?
  • What happens if the fit is wrong? How fast is a replacement?
  • Are there setup, placement or software fees beyond the hourly rate?
  • How are hours tracked and reported?
  • How is client data protected on the VA's device and network?

For Hire Heroes, the home page answers several of these: VAs are handpicked from the Hire Heroes network so there are no interviews for you to run, a dedicated VA is ready in 7 days or less, and plans are month to month with no contract. Hours, activity screenshots and login time stamps show in the Hire Heroes App.

Step 5: Set the compliance rules before day one

  1. Write the line down. One page: what the VA may do, what they hand to you, and the exact handoff sentence for coverage questions.
  2. Pay by the hour. Under the NAIC model act, unlicensed clerical staff must receive no commission on policies sold. No per sale bonuses.
  3. Medicare. If you sell Medicare Advantage or Part D, the VA calls only people who asked to be contacted, and books personal appointments with the Scope of Appointment recorded at least 48 hours ahead unless an exception applies (42 CFR 422.2264).
  4. Calling rules. If the VA dials leads, follow consent and do not call rules for every list.

Step 6: Set up access the safe way

  • A named login for every system: CRM, email, phone, quoting tools. Never share your own password.
  • Two factor sign in wherever your systems allow it.
  • Only the access the role needs. A receptionist does not need commission statements.
  • Calendar access so the VA books into your real calendar. The Hire Heroes App syncs with Google Calendar.
  • A written list of every account you opened, so you can close them the same day if you part ways.

Many states have adopted the NAIC Insurance Data Security Model Law, which requires licensees to keep an information security program. Check your state's version.

Step 7: Write short SOPs

You do not need a manual. The Hire Heroes SOP guide says to start with five key tasks. For each one, record your screen while you do it and talk through it, then turn that into a short checklist. Store everything where the work happens. Hire Heroes clients can upload SOPs and videos into a training project in the Hire Heroes App and assign each one as a task.

A good SOP answers four things: what triggers the task, the steps, what "done" looks like, and when to stop and ask you.

Step 8: Hand off gradually and review on a schedule

The Hire Heroes onboarding guide recommends a gradual start rather than handing over everything at once:

WhenWhat the VA takesWhat you do
Week 1Inbox organization, basic data entry, internal schedulingDaily check in; answer questions; fix SOP gaps
Week 2Client follow ups, CRM data upkeep, light customer serviceSpot check CRM notes; give feedback the same day
Week 3 and beyondReporting, lead follow up, campaign support, the full roleWeekly video check in
Day 30Owns the role from step 2Review the role's numbers from step 2
Day 60 to 90Second set of tasks if the first runs cleanMonthly review; decide on more hours or a second VA

Measure output, not activity. Calls answered, appointments kept, renewals contacted, records cleaned. Screenshots tell you someone was working. Only results tell you the work was right.

Mistakes we see most

  • Hiring before the role exists. The VA ends up waiting for instructions and you end up managing instead of selling.
  • Handing over everything on day one. Start with one task, measure it, then hand off the next.
  • No single system. If the work lives in your head and five apps, the VA cannot see it. Put it in the CRM. See working with a VA inside your CRM.
  • Letting the VA answer coverage questions to be helpful. Give them the handoff line and back them up when they use it.

Ready to start? Hire your hero. Which task comes off your plate first?

Frequently asked questions

What should I look for when hiring an insurance virtual assistant?

Look for experience with CRM work, phones and admin tasks, working hours that overlap your phone peaks, and clear communication. Then check the provider terms: contract length, replacement policy, any fees beyond the hourly rate and how hours are tracked.

How long does it take to onboard an insurance VA?

Plan on about three weeks of gradual handoff before the VA owns the full role, following the Hire Heroes onboarding guide: simple admin in week 1, client follow ups and CRM upkeep in week 2, and the full role from week 3.

Should my first virtual assistant be part time or full time?

If you have less than about 20 hours a week of documented tasks, start part time. Hire Heroes lists part time at $11 an hour for 80 to 159 hours a month and full time at $10 an hour for 160 to 479 hours a month.

How fast can Hire Heroes place a virtual assistant?

The Hire Heroes home page says a dedicated, vetted virtual assistant will be ready in 7 days or less, handpicked from its network so you do not run interviews.

What access should an insurance VA have?

Give a named login to each system the role needs, such as CRM, email, phone and calendar, with two factor sign in where possible. Do not share your own passwords, and keep a list of accounts so you can remove access quickly.

Sources

  1. How to Onboard a Virtual Assistant: A Step-by-Step Guide (Glen Shelton, March 18, 2025)
  2. Hire Heroes pricing and plans (hireheroes.com home page, viewed 2026-10-13)
  3. How to Build SOPs That Scale (Hire Heroes blog)
  4. How the Hire Heroes App Makes Delegation Easy (Glen Shelton, April 17, 2025)
  5. How We Use Seven Figure CRM to Nurture Leads, Automate, and Scale (May 23, 2025)
  6. NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act (#218), Sections 2 to 4
  7. 42 CFR 422.2264, beneficiary contact and Scope of Appointment rules (eCFR, current text checked October 26, 2026)
  8. NAIC Government Affairs Brief: Insurance Data Security Model Law (#668), January 2024