Every agency owner asks it the same way: "What does a VA really cost next to just hiring someone local?" Fair question. Here is the math with public numbers, the method, and the costs on both sides that a simple hourly comparison leaves out.
The in house side: wages plus benefits
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) publishes median wages for the three jobs that match agency support work. The May 2025 Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) national figures:
| Job (BLS code) | Median hourly | Median annual wage | Estimated benefits (42.9% of wages) | Estimated yearly cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Receptionists and information clerks (43-4171) | $18.27 | $38,010 | $16,300 | $54,300 |
| Customer service representatives (43-4051) | $21.53 | $44,770 | $19,200 | $64,000 |
| Insurance claims and policy processing clerks (43-9041) | $23.67 | $49,230 | $21,100 | $70,300 |
Where the benefits number comes from. The BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation survey for June 2026 shows private industry employers paying $14.07 an hour in benefits for every $32.82 an hour in wages. That is 42.9 cents of benefits per wage dollar, and it includes legally required costs such as Social Security, Medicare tax, unemployment insurance and workers compensation, plus paid leave, insurance and retirement. We multiply the median annual wage by 1.429. Figures are rounded to the nearest hundred.
This is an estimate, not a quote. A small agency with no health plan will pay less in benefits. An agency with a rich package will pay more. Wages also vary a lot by state; see virtual assistant cost by state for ten state breakdowns.
The VA side: Hire Heroes listed rates
Hire Heroes publishes one price list for every state. From the plan table on the hireheroes.com home page:
| Plan | Rate | Hours as listed | Yearly cost at that schedule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part Time, monthly | $11 per hour | 80 to 159 hours per month (20 hours a week) | $11,440 for 1,040 hours |
| Full Time, monthly | $10 per hour | 160 to 479 hours per month (40 hours a week) | $20,800 for 2,080 hours |
| Quarterly | $9 per hour | 480 or more hours (part time for 6 months or full time for 3 months) | $4,320 per 480 hour block |
Each plan lists the same inclusions: managing calendar and CRM, inbound and outbound phone calls, email management, data compiling and reporting, and following up with your clients. The site says plans are month to month with no contract, and that a dedicated VA is ready in 7 days or less.
Side by side for one full time person
| In house receptionist (U.S. median) | Hire Heroes full time VA | |
|---|---|---|
| Hourly cost to you | About $26.10 ($18.27 wage times 1.429) | $10.00 |
| Yearly cost for 2,080 hours | About $54,300 | $20,800 |
| Difference per year | About $33,500 more | About $33,500 less, or about $2,790 a month |
| Commitment | Hiring, payroll, benefits enrollment, termination process | Month to month, no contract (per hireheroes.com) |
| Time to start | Your own recruiting timeline | Ready in 7 days or less (per hireheroes.com) |
One honest note on the math: the BLS benefit ratio is per hour worked, and 2,080 hours is a full paid year. Using it on 2,080 hours slightly overstates the in house cost, because some of those hours are paid leave. It does not change the size of the gap in any meaningful way.
What the hourly math leaves out
Costs that push the in house number up
- Recruiting. Job board posts, interview time and the cost of a bad hire. Hire Heroes says its VAs are handpicked from its network, so there are no interviews for you to run.
- Space and equipment. A desk, a computer, a phone line and software seats for someone in your office.
- Turnover. When a front desk person leaves, you start recruiting and training again.
We do not put dollar figures on these because they vary too much from one agency to the next. They only push the in house number up.
Costs on the VA side you should plan for
- Your training time. Any new team member needs it. The Hire Heroes onboarding guide lays out three weeks of gradual handoff before a VA runs the bigger tasks.
- Software seats. If your CRM, quoting tool or phone system charges per user, add a seat. Hire Heroes blog posts state that Seven Figure CRM access is included when you hire a VA through Hire Heroes.
- Time zones and walk ins. A remote VA cannot greet a client in your lobby. Agree on working hours that cover your phone peaks.
- The licensing line. Neither a VA nor an unlicensed receptionist can sell, solicit or negotiate insurance. That limit is the same for both, so it does not change the cost comparison. See what an unlicensed insurance assistant can do.
The number that matters more: your hour
The cleaner way to judge any hire is what it frees up. Write down how many hours a week you spend on phones, scheduling, data entry and follow ups. Then ask what those hours would be worth if you spent them in appointments instead.
- Track one normal week. Every task that did not need your license goes on the list.
- Add up the hours. That is the size of the role.
- Price the role both ways with the tables above.
- Estimate what you would do with the freed hours, using your own closing numbers, not anyone else's.
Glen's agency made this call years ago. In a Hire Heroes post he wrote that the agency typically has fewer than 10 U.S. based employees and over 200 virtual staff members. That is a big agency with a big operation, not a forecast for yours, but it shows the model scales. Read how we use virtual assistants in our agency.
The same math for other roles
Not every agency needs a receptionist. If the work is mostly service calls and renewals, compare against the customer service representative median. If it is mostly paperwork, policy changes and commission files, the closest BLS match is the insurance claims and policy processing clerk.
| Role you would otherwise hire | Estimated in house yearly cost | Full time Hire Heroes VA | Estimated difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Receptionist | $54,300 | $20,800 | About $33,500 |
| Customer service representative | $64,000 | $20,800 | About $43,200 |
| Insurance claims and policy processing clerk | $70,300 | $20,800 | About $49,500 |
| Part time receptionist (1,040 hours) | $27,200 | $11,440 (part time plan) | About $15,700 |
The part time in house figure is half the full time estimate. In practice many part time employees get fewer benefits, so treat that row as an upper bound.
When in house is the better call
A local hire can make more sense when you need someone at a physical front desk for walk in clients, when your state or a carrier requires the person to be licensed for the role you have in mind, or when you are hiring a licensed producer rather than support staff. A licensed hire is a different job with different pay; the BLS figures above are for unlicensed support roles.
Next step
If the numbers work, the hiring guide walks through the task audit and the first 90 days. If you want to see roles first, start with the services page. How many hours a week are you spending on work that does not need your license?
Frequently asked questions
How much does an in house insurance receptionist cost per year?
At the May 2025 BLS national median of $18.27 an hour, wages are about $38,010 a year. Adding typical private industry benefits from the BLS June 2026 employer cost survey brings the estimate to about $54,300, before recruiting, space and equipment.
How much does a full time insurance virtual assistant cost per year?
Hire Heroes lists its full time plan at $10 an hour. At 2,080 hours a year that is $20,800. The part time plan is $11 an hour, or $11,440 for 1,040 hours.
How much can an agency save with a virtual assistant instead of a receptionist?
Using the U.S. median receptionist wage plus estimated benefits against the Hire Heroes full time rate, the difference is about $33,500 a year. Your number depends on your state wages, your benefits and how many hours you need.
Are there hidden costs to hiring a virtual assistant?
Plan for your own training time, any per user software seats and working hours that cover your phone peaks. A remote VA also cannot greet walk in clients. Hire Heroes posts state Seven Figure CRM access is included with a VA hire.
Sources
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, OEWS tables (May 2025 estimates)
- BLS OEWS: Receptionists and Information Clerks (43-4171)
- BLS OEWS: Customer Service Representatives (43-4051)
- BLS OEWS: Insurance Claims and Policy Processing Clerks (43-9041)
- BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026 news release
- BLS ECEC private industry benefits per hour, June 2026 (series CMU2030000000000D)
- Hire Heroes pricing and plans (hireheroes.com home page, viewed 2026-10-13)
- How We Use Virtual Assistants in Our Agency (Hire Heroes blog)
- How to Onboard a Virtual Assistant: A Step-by-Step Guide (Glen Shelton, March 18, 2025)
- How We Use Seven Figure CRM to Nurture Leads, Automate, and Scale (May 23, 2025)
