Your book is only as good as your service
Clients rarely leave because of one big mistake. They leave because of silence: the voicemail nobody returned, the ID card that never came, the renewal nobody mentioned. The Hire Heroes post on customer service in your insurance agency calls it what it is: in insurance, silence costs loyalty.
A customer service VA is the person whose whole job is making sure every client hears back.
Tasks a customer service VA handles
| Task | Example |
|---|---|
| Routine requests | Address changes, ID card requests, copies of documents, billing contact details |
| Carrier follow up | Checking pending application or claim status with the carrier and updating the client |
| Renewal and review reminders | Reminders at set intervals before a renewal or annual review, then booking the review with you |
| Post appointment follow up | Thank you message, documents you promised, next step on the calendar |
| CRM notes | Logging every call, email and life event so you walk into the next conversation prepared |
| Satisfaction checks | A short survey after a policy delivery, with low scores flagged to you the same day |
| Social inbox | Replying to messages and comments with your approved responses (see managing your social media inbox) |
In Glen's agency, VAs answer phones, order ID cards and schedule appointments, and with the right training handle more complex service work too (How We Use Virtual Assistants in Our Agency).
The escalation list
The licensing line, in plain words. Under the NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act, which most states base their law on, you need a license to "sell, solicit or negotiate" insurance. "Solicit" means asking or urging someone to apply for a particular kind of insurance from a particular company. "Negotiate" means advising a buyer on the benefits, terms or conditions of a specific policy. Plan on your Hire Heroes VA working as an unlicensed assistant, so they stay on the administrative side of that line and hand every coverage conversation to a licensed agent. Each state words its exceptions a little differently, so check yours on the NAIC directory of state insurance departments.
Write a short list your VA can follow without guessing. Escalate to the licensed agent when a client:
- Asks what their plan covers, whether a drug or doctor is covered, or what they will pay
- Wants to change, add, cancel or replace a policy
- Is upset or mentions a complaint, an appeal or a regulator
- Asks "what would you do?" about any coverage decision
For Medicare clients, be careful during the Annual Enrollment Period. A VA can send your approved reminder that review season is open and book the review, but plan comparisons belong to the agent. CMS requires the people who market Medicare Advantage plans to be licensed and appointed where state law requires (42 CFR 422.2274).
Three templates to write first
Templates are what let a VA sound like your agency instead of a call center. Start with these three and add more as requests repeat:
- "We got it." Same day acknowledgment for any request: "Thanks for reaching out, Mr. Lee. I have your request for a new ID card and I am ordering it from the carrier today. I will text you once it ships."
- Review reminder. "Your annual review with Glen is coming up. It takes about 30 minutes and he will go over any changes for next year. Here are two times that work."
- Handoff. "Great question. Glen is the right person for that one, and I have booked him to call you tomorrow at 11. Is that still a good number?"
Every template has a place for the client's name and their specific request. Generic messages feel cold; your VA fills in the details.
What changes in the first 30 days
| Week | Focus |
|---|---|
| 1 | VA shadows: reads past interactions, learns the CRM, drafts replies you approve |
| 2 | VA handles routine requests and ID cards; you review daily |
| 3 | VA owns carrier follow ups and renewal reminders |
| 4 | VA runs the full service queue; you review weekly and handle escalations |
Protect client information
Service work means your VA will see personal and sometimes health information. Give access by role, not by default: the CRM records they need, carrier portals only where your carrier agreements allow assistant access, and never your own logins. Keep everything inside your CRM and the Hire Heroes App rather than personal email or messaging apps, and review carrier and business associate agreements before granting access to health data.
What it costs
BLS reported a national median wage of $44,770 a year for customer service representatives in May 2025, about $21.52 an hour before benefits. A full time Hire Heroes VA is $10 an hour, which is $20,800 for 2,080 hours, with no benefits or payroll taxes on your side. Full plan details:
| Plan (as listed on hireheroes.com) | Hourly rate | Hours | Typical schedule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part Time, monthly | $11 per hour | 80 to 159 hours per month | 20 hours a week for 4 weeks |
| Full Time, monthly | $10 per hour | 160 to 479 hours per month | 40 hours a week for 4 weeks |
| Quarterly | $9 per hour | 480 or more hours | Part time for 6 months or full time for 3 months |
Training your service VA
- Write your service standards: how fast a reply goes out, tone, what never gets shared.
- Build templates for the 10 requests you get most.
- Record a short walkthrough of your CRM and carrier portals and load it into the Hire Heroes App.
- Role play the escalation scenarios before the VA talks to clients.
- Review interactions daily for the first few weeks, then weekly.
Our step by step guide: how to train an insurance virtual assistant.
Frequently asked questions
What customer service tasks can a VA do for an insurance agency?
A VA can handle routine requests, ID cards, carrier status checks, renewal reminders, post appointment follow up, CRM notes and satisfaction surveys. Coverage advice and policy changes stay with a licensed agent.
Can a virtual assistant talk to my insurance clients?
Yes, for service and scheduling. They should follow your templates and escalate any question about benefits, rates or which policy to choose to a licensed agent.
Can a VA help my Medicare clients during AEP?
A VA can send your approved review reminders and book annual reviews during the Annual Enrollment Period. Plan comparisons and recommendations must come from a licensed, appointed agent.
How do I keep client data safe with a virtual assistant?
Give role based access only to the systems the VA needs, keep work inside your CRM and the Hire Heroes App, never share your own logins, and check your carrier agreements before granting portal access.
Sources
- Hire Heroes pricing and plans (hireheroes.com home page, viewed 2026-10-13)
- How a Virtual Assistant Can Improve Customer Service in Your Insurance Agency (Nov 4, 2025)
- How We Use Virtual Assistants in Our Agency (Glen Shelton, July 25, 2024)
- BLS OEWS May 2025: Customer Service Representatives (43-4051)
- NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act (Model 218), Sections 2 to 4
- 42 CFR 422.2274, agent and broker requirements for Medicare Advantage
- NAIC directory of state insurance departments
